Android vs. iPhone vs. BlackBerry vs. Windows Phone
Today’s smartphones are capable of doing so much more than the mobile phones of a few years ago – but this greatly extended range of capabilities has also seen the introduction of some new security risks.
As more and more apps come onto the market, especially for the popular iOS and Android phones, their security is a growing concern no matter which mobile device you use.
Mobile devices have become both integral and ubiquitous in everyone’s lives, and so they have attracted the interest of criminal hackers eager to steal your vital information. Because we’re using our phones for a much wider range of activities – from social networking to online shopping, banking, and surfing the web – we all need to take sensible precautions to ensure our phones and our information are safe from malware attacks and cybercriminals. How secure is your mobile phone? Beyond the Android vs iPhone debate, what are your options for providing better smartphone security for yourself or your company? Here are a few tips to help you protect yourself.
Three Layers of Security
As InfoWorld notes, all smartphones have three basic elements of security. Your first major task as a mobile user is to become aware of these layers and enable them in your devices:
- Device Protection: Allowing remote data “wiping” if your device is ever lost or stolen.
- Data Protection: Preventing corporate data from being transferred to personal apps running on the same device or personal network.
- App-Management Security: Protecting your in-app information from becoming compromised.
Smartphone security depends not only on the phones, but also on the mobile device management (MDM) technology installed on company servers, that controls and manages device security. Both must work together to provide good security. You need to look at the whole picture. For example, BlackBerry phones are designed and built for business use. Their security is excellent, however BlackBerry offers few popular consumer apps. You might need another type of smartphone for personal use – including shopping and banking – meaning that you need to be concerned about that phone’s security as well. The more devices you use, especially if they are linked together through the cloud or otherwise, the more concerned you should be for the overall security of your mobile network.
Mobile technology specialist Ira Grossman, quoted at CRN, says, “if you don’t have a secure app, it doesn’t matter how secure the operating system is.” In fact, when professionals speak in terms of securing the entire “stack” of a device, they are referring to both the operating system and the apps it runs. Most phones have settings that allow you to verify any apps coming from unknown sources before downloading, and as a rule of thumb, you should stick to the Apple, Google Play, or Microsoft stores, rather than third-party app deliverers. However, always read the reviews, even in the official stores, to make sure you’re not adding anything suspicious to your device.
Android vs iPhone vs Blackberry vs Windows Phone
Android security has a questionable reputation, mainly because no one owns it—no one regulates what can or cannot be offered as an Android app, or even what can be sold as an Android phone. But, as Forbes reports, you can secure your Android phone by keeping it updated and avoiding downloading apps of unknown or doubtful origin. More recent Android devices support Google’s Android for Work, which is designed to protect workplace applications and uses. In addition, recent Android devices from Samsung also support Samsung’s own Knox security technology. Apple’s iOS mobile operating system is tightly controlled by Apple itself, which also tightly controls the apps available in the Apple App Store. This control allows Apple devices to offer good security “out of the box,” at the price of some user restrictions. For example, iOS only allows one copy of an app on each device. So if a user has a company-provided copy of an app, with security restrictions built in, the user cannot also have an unrestricted version of the same app for personal use. Blackberry also tightly controls devices and apps. Moreover, it is built for MDM, making it easier for a company to manage and protect its devices. Windows Phone also has a degree of centralized control, but has a history of security weaknesses, though its performance is improving as more and more users are coming onboard.
Pros and Cons
No one device or operating system is the definitive “best” when it comes to security. How secure your smartphone is, depends on your personal or professional needs and level of tech fluency. Here is a breakdown of the pros and cons of each type of device, along with a few things to think about when making your decision:
- Pro: Highly configurable; you can fully control your privacy settings.
- Con: Lack of standardization means weak “out of the box” security.
- Tip: Best if you are comfortable with adjusting security settings and tools.
- Pro: Consistency and reliability; you know what you are getting.
- Con: Not invulnerable to malware; heavily dependent on Apple security practice. Also, while Apple products are generally priced higher than the Android, they don’t guarantee 100% security and are still vulnerable to malware and hacking.
- Tip: Probably the simplest choice for “pretty good” security.
- Pro: Designed to provide industrial-strength enterprise security.
- Con: You will probably need a separate personal device, which may come with its own security issues.
- Tip: The best choice if you work in an industry like finance with critical security concerns.
- Pro: Compatible with Windows; steadily improving security performance.
- Con: History of uncertain security performance in the past.
- Tip: Your best bet if Windows compatibility is a top requirement.
Each smartphone option has mobile security strengths and limitations. How you use your smartphone – and how comfortable you are with adjusting its security settings – will play a big part in deciding which is the best choice for you, but there is no doubt that this debate will continue as more devices come on the market, and increased security measures become more and more important.
Did you know?
Trojans are the most prominent mobile threats: they constitute over 95% of mobile malware. Over 98% of mobile banking attacks target Android devices, which also comes as no surprise. Android is the most popular mobile platform in the world (over 80% of global smartphone market), and of all popular mobile platforms only Android allows to side-load software.
It goes without saying the history of banking Trojans is still being written: more and more new apps are created, and more and more efficient techniques attackers user to lure users into their trap. So, it is about time you protected your Android smartphone properly.
Security tips – for safer smartphone use
Here are some useful tips from Kaspersky Lab’s team of Internet security experts:
- Keep it locked: Make sure your phone’s screen lock is on – at all times – so there’s less at risk if your phone falls into the hands of a cybercriminal.
- Encrypt your sensitive information: If your phone includes data encryption features, make sure you use them. In the event of your phone being stolen, criminals will not be able to access the personal information that’s stored on your phone – if that information has already been encrypted.
- Monitor how apps behave on your phone: Be aware of permission access / requests from applications running on your phone. It’s especially important to do this for Android smartphones.
- Protect your phone and your data: Many users – that wouldn’t ever consider running a laptop, PC, or Mac computer without anti-malware software – forget that today’s smartphones are powerful computers… and they are vulnerable to the same risks. Make sure you use a reputable anti-malware program on all of your mobile devices – and ensure the antivirus databases are regularly updated.
- Be aware of the risks of jailbreaking / rooting: Although it might be tempting to root or jailbreak your phone – in order to access specific apps or services – this will strip away the security. To help keep your phone and your data secure… don’t root or jailbreak your phone.
- Switch off Bluetooth… when you can: If you’re not using your Bluetooth connection, it’s a great idea to switch it off. That way, you’ll make your phone less vulnerable to cyberattack… and you’ll reduce the drain on your phone’s battery.
- Choose a smartphone security solution with anti-theft features: Some smartphone security products include a range of anti-theft features that give you remote access to your lost or stolen phone – so you can lock the phone, wipe data from it, and find its location.